Landscape fabric comparison

Three fabrics. One right answer for your ground.

SHIELD, XBAR, and TERRA are not three grades of the same thing. They are three constructions built for three different ground conditions. This landscape fabric comparison shows exactly what changes between them.

Which DOTDAY fabric is right for you?

Choose by the ground condition, not by the weight alone. Each column below is one fabric, and every band lines up the same property across all three.

Skid steer dropping gravel onto DOTDAY XBAR dual-layer hardscape fabric

XBAR

Load and separation under gravel, pavers, and traffic.

From $44.99
DOTDAY SHIELD woven weed barrier fabric over a garden planting row

SHIELD

Weed control for beds, rows, and everything under mulch.

From $64.49
Dump truck filling a timber-framed pad lined with TERRA non-woven geotextile

TERRA

Drainage and filtration that keeps soil and stone apart.

From $58.49
5 oz

Woven top plus non-woven backing

Dual-layer

3.2 oz

Woven polypropylene

Flat-tape weave

4/6/8 oz

Non-woven needle-punched

Felt-like fiber mat

10.5

gal/min/sf under load

ASTM D4491

Permeable weave

Water and air reach the roots

3,300

l/min/m2 at 8 oz

ASTM D4491

332 lb

CBR puncture resistance

ASTM D6241

180/105 lb

Grab strength MD/CD

ASTM D4632

500 lb

CBR puncture at 8 oz

ASTM D6241

Gravel, pavers, driveways, hardscape

9 roll sizes, from $0.27/sq ft

Beds, mulch, farm rows, nurseries

6 roll sizes, from $0.07/sq ft

French drains, walls, road base

3 weights, from $0.39/sq ft

Head to head

Pick two. See exactly what changes.

DOTDAY Fabric Comparison
XBAR vs SHIELD
XBARAttributeSHIELD
Weed control
Takes load
10.5 gal/min/sfWater flowPermeable
Filters fines
Plant through it
5 ozFabric weight3.2 oz
$0.27Best per sq ft$0.07

Each fabric in detail

XBAR dual-layer fabric laid as a garden path beside raised beds and a greenhouse

Available in 9 roll sizes

XBAR

From $44.99 per roll, or $0.17 per sq ft.
5 oz dual-layer woven. Nine roll sizes.

Shop XBAR
  • Two layers, one job each.The woven face carries the load; the needle-punched backing blocks light and stops pumping.

  • 332 lb CBR puncture resistance.ASTM D6241, so angular stone and machine traffic do not open it up.

  • 10.5 gal/min/sf water flow.ASTM D4491. Breathable under load instead of pooling beneath the surface.

  • 12 inch guide stripes.Keeps rows, cuts, and overlaps straight across a long run.

  • 29.5 mil thickness, sealed edges.Cuts clean with a knife and does not unravel.

Buying guides. Still deciding? Start here.

Full specification

Landscape fabric comparison, line by line

Every number below is published on the product page it comes from.

Landscape fabric comparison, line by line
Attribute
5 oz dual-layer
3.2 oz woven
4 / 6 / 8 oz non-woven
Build
ConstructionWoven top plus non-woven backingWoven polypropyleneNon-woven needle-punched
12 inch plant guide lines in yellowYesYesNo
Water
BehaviorThrough the weave, under loadThrough the weaveThrough the body of the mat
Flow rate10.5 gal/min/sfPermeable3,300 l/min/m2 at 8 oz
Filters silt and finesNoNoYes
Strength
Grab tensile96/68 lb180/105 lb205 lb at 8 oz
CBR puncture332 lbNot rated for load500 lb at 8 oz
UV strength at 500 hrs70%70%Not UV rated, cover after install
Buy
Roll options9 sizes6 sizes3 weights
Starting price$44.99$64.49$58.49
Best price per sq ft$0.27$0.07$0.39

TERRA figures are for the 8 oz weight. The 4 oz and 6 oz share the same construction at lower mass. Prices are per roll before promotion and exclude 3 x 10 ft sample rolls.

Free US shipping No minimum on every roll size
30-day refund or replacement On your first roll
Ships from US warehouses Contractor and farm volumes
Lab-tested to ASTM methods · U.S. company Data sheets on request
Size your job

Know which fabric. Now work out how much.

Enter your bed or pad dimensions and the calculator returns strip count, overlap, and the exact roll sizes to order.

Use the Fabric Calculator

Before you order

Which DOTDAY landscape fabric should I choose?

Choose by ground condition. SHIELD 3.2 oz woven is for weed control in beds, rows, and under mulch. XBAR 5 oz dual-layer is for gravel, pavers, and anything carrying traffic or load. TERRA non-woven is for drainage, filtration, and soil separation. If two apply, buy both and use each where it belongs.

Can I use SHIELD under gravel to save money?

No. SHIELD is built for weed control under mulch and soil, not sustained load. Under gravel or pavers it will pump and tear, and the repair costs more than the fabric ever saved. XBAR is the fabric rated for that job at 332 lb CBR puncture resistance.

What is the difference between landscape fabric and geotextile?

They are different tools. Woven landscape fabric such as SHIELD suppresses weeds while staying permeable. A non-woven geotextile such as TERRA is engineered so water passes through the body of the mat while silt and fines are filtered out. Weed suppression versus water movement is the whole distinction.

Which TERRA weight do I need?

4 oz suits simple drainage and separation. 6 oz is the versatile middle for French drains and retaining wall backfill. 8 oz handles road base and heavier stabilization. Match the weight to the load above it and how much filtration the job demands.

Is XBAR just a heavier weed barrier?

Not quite. XBAR pairs a woven polypropylene top that carries load with a non-woven needle-punched backing that blocks light and stops stone pumping into the soil. It is a separation fabric that also suppresses weeds, not a thicker version of a garden barrier.

What is the difference between 3.2 oz and 5 oz weed barrier?

Weight is only part of it. SHIELD at 3.2 oz is a single woven layer made for beds and rows you plant through. XBAR at 5 oz adds a non-woven backing, 29.5 mil thickness, and a 332 lb CBR puncture rating, which is what lets it sit under gravel and pavers. Pick by where the fabric goes, then the weight follows.

Ready to order

Use the right fabric for the right ground condition.

Still deciding? FabricFinder matches you in under a minute. Buying for a job site? Send the dimensions and we will quote it.